overated....underated?

[hehateme71]

ok I am gonna list a few NBA players, next too them put if you say they are underated or overated, who cares what people think of your answers so be honest, and dont try to go with the majority of the people, just give honest answers:

shawn marion- underated

vince carter- a tad bit overated

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- underated

ray allen- overated (no defense)

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- overated

Baron davis- underated

emeka okafor- overated (he plays on expansion anyone could put up good numbers)

dwight howard- overated he he...

paul pierce- extreamly underated

Mike bibby- overated (he has a lot of help)

[Magus Relmyn]

shawn marion - underated

vince carter - overated

pau gasol - underated

dirk nowitzki - rated just fine

ray allen - overated

zack randolph - underated

michael redd - underated

andre miller - overated

Baron davis - rated just fine

emeka okafor - rated just fine

dwight howard - rated just fine

paul pierce - underated

mike bibby - overated

[thechadman2]

shawn marion- underated

vince carter- neutral

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- neutral

ray allen- neutral

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- neutral

Baron davis- underated

emeka okafor- don't know yet

dwight howard- don't know yet

paul pierce- neutral

Mike bibby- overated, only good in playoffs.

[bravest]

Shawn Marion- under

Vince Carter- over

Pau Gasol- over

Dirk Nowitzki- under

Ray Allen- under

Zack Randolph- under

Michael Redd- under

Andre Miller- over

Baron Davis- over

Emeka Okafor- under

Dwight Howard- over

Paul Pierce- over

Mike Bibby- over

[paranoidmoonduck]

shawn marion- underappreciated not underrated

vince carter- has people constantly look at his potential, so yes, overrated

pau gasol- absolutely underrated

dirk nowitzki- rated just right

ray allen- underrated, people don't appreciate good shooter anymore

zack randolph- underrated, but a new star, so it is understandable

michael redd- same answer as ray allen, but redd is even more underrated

andre miller- underrated, is a great passer, even lead the league year in and year out with the cavs pre-Lebron.

Baron davis- overrated. He is way to inconsistent. He is constantly riding the line between great scorer to ball hog, much like kobe.

emeka okafor- can't be rated after a few weeks in the NBA, but has great potential

dwight howard- can't be rated but is off to a great start

paul pierce- rated based on team performance.

Mike bibby- I never thought he was rated very highly, so rated just right

[twins15]

shawn marion- just right

vince carter- used to be overrated, now people realize he's not that good

pau gasol- just right

dirk nowitzki- overrated

ray allen- just right, though underrated at the moment cause he is shooting so well

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- overrated

andre miller- underrated

Baron davis- underrated

emeka okafor- overrated

dwight howard- underrated

paul pierce- just right

Mike bibby- overrated

[McMaster]

shawn marion- underated

vince carter- overated

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- Even

Ray Allen- Underrated

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- overated

Baron davis- underated some times overrated

emeka okafor- Even
dwight howard- even

paul pierce- underated

Mike bibby- overated

[wolves025]

shawn marion- underated

vince carter- overrated

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- underated

ray allen- underrated never hear alot bout him

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- overated

Baron davis- underated

emeka okafor- he is a rook to soon to tell

dwight howard- he is a rook to soon to tell

paul pierce- same

Mike bibby- overrated

Thing is different players are promoted in different areas differently. Like you will hear more bout a star player in the same division more then one in a different conference as long as there not MVP type.

[Booksman]

ok I am gonna list a few NBA players, next too them put if you say they are underated or overated, who cares what people think of your answers so be honest, and dont try to go with the majority of the people, just give honest answers:

shawn marion- underrated

vince carter- a tad bit overrated

pau gasol- don't like him but I guess underrated

dirk nowitzki- underrated

ray allen- overrated

zack randolph- not that good

michael redd- underrated

andre miller- overrated

Baron davis- overrated

emeka okafor- overrated

dwight howard- overated

paul pierce- overrated

Mike bibby- overrated

Andrei Kirilenko- underrated...

[Scott Proctor]

dirk nowitzki- underated
andre miller- overated
Baron davis- underated
emeka okafor- overated (he plays on expansion anyone could put up good numbers)
dwight howard- overated he he...
paul pierce- extreamly underatedNowitzki is awful on defense, especially since he plays the 3 and is a 7-footer. Miller-overrated? Since when? He led the league in assists 2 years ago, he seems more underrated to me. Baron Davis isn't underrated. He has is a great point guard right now but he gets what he deserves even though he always lets his team down when he gets injured. How can anyone put up good numbers on a team that bad? Jason Hart/Omar Cook/Kevin Ollie at point guard? The next best player is Gerald Wallace and all he can do is dunk. He can't feed off horrible teammates. Howard, overrated? No comment. Paul Pierce-EXTREMELY OVERRATED. Without Antoine Walker on his team he couldn't get them into the playoffs last year. Being the superstar-status player that he is he should be able to lead a decent team into the playoffs in that weak Eastern Conference.

[slinky]

Pierce did,8th seed and lost to the Pacers.


How is Howard and Okafor overrated? Both have better numbers than other players drafted in their situation. And almost every rookie are hyped.

[Street]

shawn marion - over

vince carter - over

pau gasol - under

dirk nowitzki - over

ray allen - under

zack randolph - under

michael redd - under

andre miller - over

Baron davis - over

emeka okafor - under

dwight howard - over

paul pierce - under

mike bibby - over

[PacMan]

shawn marion- overrated (overpayed)

vince carter- overated

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- rated fine

ray allen- rated fine

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- rated fine

Baron davis- rated fine

emeka okafor- rated fine

dwight howard- rated fine

paul pierce- rated fine

Mike bibby- overated

[doublee]

Okay, two things here. One is how can a guy who has made an All Star game or played on the 'Dream Team' be underrated? Two is you cannot really say a guy who has only played ten games in the league is either underrated or overrated.

[slinky]

How exactly is Andre Miller overrated? He is rated just fine, not elite, but still a stud. Vince Carter is the only overrated player on that list, uncapable of leading a team or even being the franchise player.

[DONtheGREAT23]

shawn marion- underated

vince carter- overrated but still has the talent to pull himself up to that rating

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- about right

ray allen- about right

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- overrated

Baron davis- about right

emeka okafor- cant really rate him yet

dwight howard- cant really rate him yet

paul pierce- about right

Mike bibby- about right

[NomarFan5]

shawn marion- overrated as hell

vince carter- fine

pau gasol- underrated

dirk nowitzki- fine

ray allen- fine

zack randolph- overrated

michael redd- underrated

andre miller- underrated

Baron davis- was underrated, but now overrated

emeka okafor- same as howard

dwight howard- cant tell yet because hes had like a whole 10 games in the league or something close to it

paul pierce- fine

Mike bibby- underrated

[BigJabber]

shawn marion- overated, not the best shooter, not good in the paint either.

vince carter- wayyyy overated

pau gasol- underated

dirk nowitzki- neither

ray allen- neither

zack randolph- underated

michael redd- underated

andre miller- neither

Baron davis- overrated

emeka okafor- dont know yet, has played fine to date

dwight howard- dont know yet, has played fine to date

paul pierce- most underated player in the nba

Mike bibby- underated, he is what makes sacramento good

[BigJabber]

Vince Carter is the only overrated player on that list, uncapable of leading a team or even being the franchise player.

I concur. Carter could the most overated player in the NBA, or atleast one of them.