PDA

View Full Version : Gamepro interview: Phil Harrison, (Good stuff!!)


Crossbar
05-15-2006, 12:32 PM
Here are some more details about the background of the motion sensing control, backward compatibility etc.

I like this: "we will have what we believe will be almost perfect backwards compatibility."
Sounds good to me. :)

Exclusive: Sony's Phil Harrison Tells All on PS3, Peter Moore, Nintendo Wii
by GamePro Staff.
In an exclusive interview with GamePro editor Bro Buzz, Sony's resident PlayStation 3 expert, Phil Harrison, touches on a variety of topics: Xbox exec Peter Moore's praise for the Nintendo Wii, pricing for PS3 games and hardware, and rumors concerning the PS3's abilities.
GamePro editor Bro Buzz had the opportunity to sit down with Sony's corporate executive and PlayStation 3 frontman, Phil Harrison. The two industry veterans spoke about a wide range of topics, and the following are the key highlights from that conversation, in Harrison's words. Sony fans should take note: there are quite a few fascinating PS3 tidbits revealed in this sprawling, three-page article.

...On Peter Moore's Praise for the Nintendo Wii

Sony's Phil Harrison debuts the PlayStation 3 controller at E3 2006
"I think Peter Moore is exactly right. I think Nintendo will be the second system consumers purchase after PlayStation 3."

"I haven't had a chance to check out the Wii myself, but Nintendo has a great history of innovation and has always done great things for gaming and long may they do so. But as it relates to our strategy they are very much in a different market."

"I know what Peter was getting at with his price point issue but he's not comparing apples to oranges. He's not even comparing the same kind of food products at all. It's clearly a case that PlayStation 3's price is justified by PlayStation 3's value. That's what consumers base their purchasing decisions on -- value."

Frankly, I'm amazed that we can [sell the PS3] so cheaply."What we have in addition to a great game system is a Blue Ray player, a network platform, a new controller, and HDD in every system combined in an unbelievably compelling package. And frankly I'm amazed that we can do it so cheaply."

...On the Differences Between the 20 and 60 GB PS3 Models
"The main differences are the 60 GB drive and the 20 GB drive in terms of disc storage. The 20 GB has HD component rather than HDMI. The 60 GB machine has additionally memory card slots on it, which are great for archiving photo and other content. But the 20 GB machine has USB ports so you can get all the functionality with external devices."

...On Whether the 20 GB PS3 Will Fully Support Blu-Ray

The $599 60 GB PS3 (top) looks different from the $499 20 GB PS3 (bottom)
"That seems to be a misunderstanding and I'm happy to clear that up. Both machines have Blue Ray disc as standard. Both machines play Blue Ray disc movies as standard. Both machines will play Blue Ray disc movies as HD. The only difference is that the high end machine uses a more convenient digital interconnect called HDMI which is a digital standard and the 20 GB unit uses HD component which is an analog standard. The picture quality is fantastic."

"The end user will not notice any quality difference. Perhaps if you were projecting onto a gi-normous screen you might notice some difference, but also not every HD display has HDMI. So we're providing a choice to the consumer."

"Both versions will support 1080p."

...On PS3 Game Prices
"We've not announced the [PS3 game] pricing yet. Clearly we will wait until closer to launch until we announce the catalog and lineup of titles."

...On the New PS3 Controller
Nobody in the world picked that [original PS3 boomerang] controller up and held it in their hands. . . . [that's because] it was always a design concept."As you will remember when we showed the controller last year every photograph showed the comment 'This is a design concept subject to change.' Nobody in the world picked that controller up and held it in their hands -- nobody did -- because it was always under glass. But everybody formed an opinion based on what it looked like."

"[The PS3 boomerang controller] was always a design concept. If you look at our controller design R&D group in Japan since 1994, in an area of their office they probably have hundreds of design concepts for controllers and [the boomerang] is just one of them."

[B]...On the PS3 Controller's Wii-Like Motion Sensor

PS3 mastermind Ken Kutaragi shows off the redesigned PS3 controller
"As mentioned, this R&D group in Japan is constantly looking at innovation in both useability, technology, and various other sensing devices and what happens is they will invent something or plan something but it can't be built because of cost reasons or supply reasons. Obviously when we make a controller we have to sell over 100 million of them so we have to make sure we have sufficient quantity of them in order to ramp up."

"I think what happened was the evolution of sensing technology was getting high enough volume in manufacture and low enough in price that we could adopt it in our controller. Now clearly we were not the only ones who thought this at the same time. But that's fine. That's natural."

"That's what technology innovation is about, but I think where we have an advantage is that shape of a controller like the PS2 controller has become like an industry standard. There's like 370 million [PlayStation controllers] around the world so that by maintaining the primary man-machine interface as something that is very familiar we have a lot of benefits to the gameplay because not only do you have the controller you're familiar with but now have additional motion."


The new PS3 controller has softer, more trigger-like R2 and L2 buttons
"We can now do with this controller what human beings do anyway which is move the controller around when they play games. So now as a game designer we can take that additional [motion-sensing] input and add it to the game experience either in a very obvious way or in a very subtle way. And we're now experimenting with various ways to do this."

...On Backwards Compatibility
[The PS3 will have] almost perfect backwards compatibility. There will be some exceptions, but we believe those will be even less than we saw from PSOne to PS2."Backwards compatibility, as you know from PlayStation One and PlayStation 2, is a core value of what we believe we should offer. And access to the library of content people have created, bought for themselves, and accumulated over the years is necessary to create a format. PlayStation is a format meaning that it transcends many devices -- PSOne, PS2, and now PS3."

"If the developer wrote the game according to our technical requirements checklist, we will have what we believe will be almost perfect backwards compatibility. There will be some exceptions, there always are, but we believe those will be very few and far between. Even less so than we saw from PSOne to PS2."

...On Microsoft's Difficulties with Xbox 360 Backward Compatibility
"I don't believe that was backwards compatibility."

...On the Importance of the PS3's Hard Drive

The standard hard drive allows for downloadable content, but also better graphics -- just look at Heavenly Sword
"We know that the future of gaming is in a network era, and we have to have a writeable format. We have to have a format were users can purchase and download online and the only way to do that is with a hard disc drive."

"The 60 gig capacity is not only to download but to archive locally. The 60 gig solution will be attractive to users who want to PS3 as their primary music players, like me. I will put my entire music collection onto my PlayStation 3. I will archive all of my photos onto my PlayStation 3. It seems like a really insignificant feature but being able to simply slideshow your photos on your tv is actually a really compelling feature of PlayStation 3."

"And over time, downloading HD content -- whether it be TV content, film content -- clearly needs a lot of hard drive space."

...On the PS3's PSP Support

The 60 GB model will support Memory Sticks, which helps bridge content from the PS3 to the PSP
"With the PSP you've seen that, over time, the operating system has been upgraded to include many new features and functionalities and capabilities and we will do the same regarding the PS3. We will see the two devices become much more interoperable both at a media level, allowing content from one to the other, and at the applications level, where games for the PS3 will have a PSP component and vice versa. We demonstrated at the press conference one example of this where the PSP serves as a wing mirror for a driving game, a Formula One game."

"That was not intended to be a gimmick, but a feature we will add to the PS3 version so that when you play the PS3 version you can gameshare from the PS3 to the PSP the program required to do that. That will be a free of charge component that we ship on the PS3."

...On Memory Stick Support
"The PlayStation 3 60 GB version has Memory Stick slots and you can use Memory Stick as a support mechanism between the PSP and PS3."
http://www.gamepro.com/news.cfm?article_id=55089

Garfunkel
05-15-2006, 02:09 PM
very interesting

masteratt
05-15-2006, 02:18 PM
Thanks a lot dude, excellent.
More people should read this as this is the closest article to define what PS3 is about.

OmniCloud
05-15-2006, 02:48 PM
Yeah good find...Phil isn't afraid to talk to gaming community-people need to read this as soon as every1 stops freakin out over the price-tag...It was eventually going to happen-everyone wants all the features and Hdd included and blue-ray but shudder at what it actually cost-get the $500 or wait for a price-drop, other than that, shut up and stop complaining! I agree Masterratt, this is a good summary of what the PS3 is all about-and it looks to be about enhancing entertainment to the next level!

and seems the biggest difference between the 2 versions really is the Hdd space-Wi-fi is just a luxury and HDMI isn't as serious as every1 thinks-it won't even be a real difference untill like 2009-and still most people will be satisfied w/the resolution they can get without HDMI...I can't wait till next-gen kicks off w/all 3 systems on the market...

Applefiend
05-15-2006, 02:58 PM
Sweet. All I want to see confirmed is BC is 99%. First year of a consoles life you mostly play old stuff, as the new stuff is thin on the ground.

Flaming_Gamer
05-15-2006, 03:03 PM
great find, rep+ :king:

gnznroses
05-16-2006, 03:51 AM
why does nobody ask about about MEMORY CARDS?....

TEEDA
05-16-2006, 11:27 AM
french video of the console :

http://playlist.yahoo.com/makeplaylist.dll?SID=25018734

Fazares
05-16-2006, 12:56 PM
this should put an end to the claims saying the 20gb ps3 isnt capable of reading bd movies....i have an xbox360,and hd component is great.....
of course wouldnt be pointless to promote ps3 as a common bd rom player if the cheapest version cant play bd movies,wouldnt it?

venomv
05-16-2006, 01:41 PM
Why? It can, just not at 1080p..........

martel
05-16-2006, 02:11 PM
As I said in another thread:

First off it's not HDMI that you need, but HDCP compliance, which covers HDMI and HDCP compliant DVI (not all DVI is HDCP compliant). If you have these you are fine.

If you're using a non compliant interface, say component, then you are at the mercy of the dreaded ICT or Image Constraint Token. This is a flag (a single value, either on or off) on BluRay and HD-DVD discs, as required by AACS (copyright agreement). Each disc has one of these token values on it, and it is up to the movie studio as to whether then leave it off (the movie will play at hi def through a component cable) or switch it on (the signal will be down "rezzed" to 540x960 on a component cable). I think Sony/MGM and Disney have said they won't be using ICT, but others like Warner will be using it.

Component can deliver a HD signal, that's not the problem, the problem is that copyright issues mean it can't display ICT checked stuff at full res. Games will be fine in HD through component. It's like with PS2 "green screen".

Having said that it has been going around that M$ and Sony were getting thi set back until 2010 due to the lack of HMDI TVs and HDCP monitors around, but I haven't seen anything official.

NickSCFC
05-16-2006, 02:27 PM
Both versions of PS3 can do 1080p.

How will the cheap version do game saves without any memory slots. Do game saves go to the HDD?

PS, Teeda's vid is of 2005's PS3.

stanDarsh
05-16-2006, 02:57 PM
I'd imagine they'd go to the HDD or to a USB pen drive.

cliffbo
05-16-2006, 03:06 PM
rest easy folks

Wi-Fi and memory card adaptors on the way

Speaking to GamesIndustry.biz, Sony has dismissed rumours that the 20GB PS3 will not be compatible with wireless controllers, and that consumers will not have the option to upgrade the hard drive.

"Both queries to my knowledge are completely false," a spokesperson told GI.biz.

"Both configurations will support bluetooth PS3 controllers. The only non-upgradeable feature of the 20GB configuration will be the HDMI output."

This confirms comments made by Sony's Phil Harrison in a recent interview with GI.biz, where he stated: "You can upgrade to whatever size of drive you like. You can put in any drive that you like - it is a computer, after all."

The spokesperson went on to reveal that Sony plans to release a Wi-Fi adaptor for the 20GB PlayStation 3. Consumers will also have the option to purchase a separate adaptor that will allow the use of memory sticks, SD cards and compact flash cards with the machine.

However, there's still no word as to whether the 20GB PlayStation 3 will make it to the UK at all.


http://www.gametab.com/news/571687/

Arnaud_M
05-16-2006, 04:38 PM
Phil is speaking of Memory Stick has the way to transfer data between PS3 and PSP. Does that mean that we will not be able to use WiFi for this ?! Was it not the original plan, to be able to transfer wirelessly between the two ? Did I missed something ?

Arnaud

DofD
05-16-2006, 06:14 PM
You can transfer data via WiFi, via USB, via Memory Stick. The user can choose which method they want to use, depending on the application.

yoshaw
05-17-2006, 03:55 AM
I'd stopped reading gamepro a long time ago. But it was a good magazine no doubt. Speaking of magazines, the unlucky me found out that I can get free EGM mag by filling out a survey for Mercury Magazines but guess what the free offer is only for people in the US. Sucks Uwe Balls. Here's the link anyway, try if it helps you.

http://www.mercurymagazines.com/pr1/101/10115

Zer0-Sum
05-17-2006, 04:04 AM
That was great crossbar! +rep man.

Phil unloaded on this one. I guess once E3 happened they gave them all permission to just talk it all up. That answered a lot of my questions. So much good info.

600 bucks for a Media Computer of this power? Are people joking when they say it is too much? Get a life folks, cause all the PS3 haters are smoking the crack.

BTW, also good find Cliffbo! Ungradable after all!! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! I laugh at PS3 haters....