IGN Gives It A 10

[[[tavis]]]

Any other game other than Oot get a 10 rating from IGN, i Know Halo only got a 9.7, hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

[The Dude]

Soul Calibur for DC got a 10

Majora's Mask got a 9.9

Metroid Prime got a 9.8

wind waker got a 9.6

[[[tavis]]]

Soul Calibur for DC got a 10

Majora's Mask got a 9.9

Metroid Prime got a 9.8

wind waker got a 9.6


SC got a 10, wow, not a good idea. good game, just not a 10.

[MCKingKongMushi]

Shenmue got a 9.7, and it's better than every game that's been listed in this thread.

[dncardman]

Hah! OOT is THE BEST game EVER!

[Michael]

The Gamespot even gave SC a 10 for the dreamcast...

[Pro A.]

OOT might deserve a 10.

Majora's Mask is probably a 9.4

Soul Calibur, think 8.7

Shenmue would get a 7.5 out of me.

MP with a 9.8 is about right.

WW is about right with its score.

[IEatFriedPikmin]

I think they give games scores according to other games on the system... kinda like a ranking. IGN Dreamcast gave Sonic Adventure 2 like a 9.6 and IGNCube gave it a 6.9. I don't know for sure though.

[neo999955]

Games IGN has given a 10:

Title | System | Developer | Publisher
Checkered Flag Lynx Atari Atari
Dragon Warrior III GBC Enix Enix
Joust Lynx Shadowsoft Shadowsoft
Magical Tetris Challenge GBC Capcom Capcom
Mario Golf GBC Camelot Software Planning Nintendo
Metal Gear Solid GBC Konami OSA Konami
Pokemon Blue GB Nintendo Nintendo
Pokemon Gold GBC Nintendo Nintendo
Pokemon Red GB Nintendo Nintendo
Pokemon Silver GBC Nintendo Nintendo
Pokemon Yellow: Special Pikachu Edition GB Nintendo Nintendo
Shanghai Lynx Atari Atari
SNK vs. Capcom: Match of the Millennium NGPC SNK SNK
Sonic Pocket Adventure NGPC SNK SNK
Soul Calibur DC Namco Namco
Super Mario Bros. Deluxe GBC Nintendo Nintendo
The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening DX GBC Nintendo Nintendo
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time N64 Nintendo Nintendo
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages GBC Flagship Nintendo
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons GBC Flagship Nintendo
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow Cell Gameloft Gameloft

Conker's Bad Fur Day got a 9.9, but it really should've been a 10. The only titles to get a 9.9 are:

Advance Wars GBA Intelligent Systems Nintendo
Conker's Bad Fur Day N64 Rare Rare
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask N64 Nintendo Nintendo
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 DC Treyarch Activision

And finally, 9.8s:

Gran Turismo 2 PS Polyphony Digital Sony Computer Entertainment
Gran Turismo 3 A-spec PS2 Polyphony Digital Sony Computer Entertainment
Metal Gear Solid PS Konami Konami
Metroid Prime GCN Retro Studios, Inc. Nintendo
Perfect Dark N64 Rare Nintendo
Super Mario 64 N64 Nintendo Nintendo
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater DC Treyarch Crave Entertainment

Nintendo is the leading Publisher, coming home with 3 out of 7 for 9.8, 2 out of 4 for 9.9, and 11 out of 21 for perfect 10s. The Legend of Zelda also walks away with four 10s and one 9.9, pretty damn impressive.

Devloper wise Nintendo has 1 out of 7 for 9.8, 1 out of 4 for 9.9, and 8 out of 21 for 10.

[Viper]

Quality over Quanitity = lots of quality in the long run.

[C.J.]

So says IGN. Quality is in the eye of the player.

[Rabunis]

All the quality in the world are belong to nintendo

[Haris]

All the gayness in the world are belong to b00nis.

[Serene Samus]

]']SC got a 10, wow, not a good idea. good game, just not a 10.


Not a good idea? WTF is that supposed to mean? Halo didn't get a 10. Was that a, "bad idea?" Are all the Halo fanboys going to kill everyone at IGN now?

[speed stick]

Wow, a lot of games I never heard of that got 10.